Bowline on Sydney Harbour.
Nick Smith, one of two sailors to die in the Sydney to Hobart Yacht Race, was competing on Bowline. Image by Paul Bramble/AAP PHOTOS
  • sailing

Deaths rock Sydney to Hobart, LawConnect leads fleet


December 27, 2024

The Sydney to Hobart yacht race has been left reeling after the deaths of two sailors in wild weather that has forced a fifth of the fleet to retire.

Supermaxi LawConnect was in the box seat on Friday evening to take out line honours for a second year running after rival Master Lock Comanche pulled the pin with mainsail damage.

South Australian Nick Smith, 65, and 55-year-old West Australian Roy Quaden were killed in separate incidents on Thursday’s first night of racing off the coast of NSW.

Smith, competing on Bowline in his fifth Sydney to Hobart, hit his head on a winch after being thrown across the yacht when he was struck by the boat’s main sheet.

Quaden was hit by the boom – the large horizontal pole at the bottom of the mainsail – while aboard Flying Fish Arctos. 

Both crews, who subsequently retired from the event and limped back to shore, performed CPR on the men but couldn’t save them. 

“It’s tragic. You’re expecting an adventure … to do something really special and something like this happens,” David Jacobs, vice-commodore of race organiser, the Cruising Yacht Club of Australia, told a media conference.

Flying Fish Arctos.
 Roy Quaden died aboard Flying Fish Arctos, shown here contesting the 2017 race. Image by Carlo Borlenghi/AAP PHOTOS 

The deaths were the first in the 628-nautical mile race since the 1998 event in which six sailors lost their lives in storms, prompting mass safety protocol reforms. 

As at 5.30pm on Friday, 22 yachts from the 104-strong starting fleet had retired, citing a range of problems including crew injuries, damage and electrical issues.

Porco Rosso had to recover a crew member who was swept overboard in the early hours of the morning in darkness. 

Jacobs said there was no consideration given to calling off the race.

“It is a fundamental principle of yacht racing, that once the race starts, the skipper has the right and the obligation to decide whether it is safe to continue,” he said.

“We have a complex structure around the race to help with safety, if we cancel the race that structure falls away.”

LawConnect.
 LawConnect is bearing down on line honours for the second year running. Image by Andrea Francolini/AAP PHOTOS 

Jacobs said Bowline and Flying Fish Arctos were dealing with winds of 30-38 knots and seas of 2-3m. 

He was adamant forecasters did not warn organisers of fatal weather, but conceded conditions played a part in the incidents, which will be investigated.

“The forecast was strong winds to gale force winds,” Jacobs said.

“The weather … these boats and these crews are used to, they train for, the boats are prepared for, but they were challenging conditions.” 

In a pre-race interview, LawConnect’s skipper Christian Beck said the weather was likely to bring the worst Sydney to Hobart conditions he’d seen.

“There was plenty of water on deck and down below,” LawConnect crew member Tony Mutter said in a social media post made at sea.

Master Lock Comanche.
 Master Lock Comanche retired in the early hours of Friday while leading the race. Image by Mick Tsikas/AAP PHOTOS 

LawConnect appears likely to cross the line in the early hours of Saturday morning, well short of the race record of one day, nine hours, 15 minutes and 24 seconds.

It was some 10 nautical miles ahead of Celestial V70 at 6pm on Friday.

Flying Fish Arctos, a NSW-based 50-footer designed for around the world sailing, had contested 17 previous Sydney to Hobart events. 

It arrived at Jervis Bay on Friday morning, while Bowline was escorted by police to Batemans Bay.

Master Lock Comanche withdrew from the race 63nm off Green Cape in the early hours of Friday while leading the fleet.

It was the first time the quadruple line honours champion, one of the most impressive monohull yachts in the world, had retired in its nine editions of the race.

Comanche had been chasing atonement for last year when LawConnect claimed line honours by 51 seconds in a tit-for-tat battle in the River Derwent.